Partner with us for a cleaner, greener and more sustainable future!
Why Raw Manure Application Is No Longer Sustainable: Scientific and Regulatory Perspectives
June, 2025, Bio Cycle Labs
In light of tightening regulations, environmental degradation, and nutrient inefficiencies, raw manure is now being reconsidered as a waste stream that requires stabilization and processing, rather than a direct input.
Manure has long been regarded as a natural fertilizer, offering a source of nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), potassium (K), and organic matter.
However, direct application of untreated manure to agricultural fields is increasingly seen as unsustainable and even counterproductive - both environmentally and agronomically.
However, direct application of untreated manure to agricultural fields is increasingly seen as unsustainable and even counterproductive - both environmentally and agronomically.
Although manure contains essential macro- and micronutrients, its nutrient ratios often do not align with crop demands:
- Manure typically contains excess phosphorus relative to nitrogen, leading to P accumulation in soils over time.
- Nitrogen losses can be significant due to ammonia volatilization, denitrification, and leaching - especially when manure is not immediately incorporated.
Environmental Impact
The environmental risks of raw manure application are well-documented and include:
These issues are particularly critical in Nitrate Vulnerable Zones (NVZs) under the EU Nitrates Directive and in areas under strict nutrient management policies such as the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) framework.
The environmental risks of raw manure application are well-documented and include:
- Nitrate leaching into groundwater and drinking water sources, especially in regions with shallow water tables or sandy soils;
- Phosphorus runoff, contributing to eutrophication and harmful algal blooms in surface waters;
- Greenhouse gas emissions from methane (CH₄) and nitrous oxide (N₂O) during storage and field application;
- Pathogen loading (e.g., E. coli, Salmonella) in runoff and on crops, posing food safety and public health concerns.
These issues are particularly critical in Nitrate Vulnerable Zones (NVZs) under the EU Nitrates Directive and in areas under strict nutrient management policies such as the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) framework.
Regulatory and Compliance Constraints
Many jurisdictions now impose strict limitations on:
Non-compliance can result in fines, lost subsidies, or environmental penalties - making raw manure increasingly risky to apply without further processing.
Many jurisdictions now impose strict limitations on:
- Application timing (e.g., closed seasons to avoid winter runoff);
- Application rates (e.g., max 170 kg N/ha/year from organic sources in the EU);
- Buffer zones and incorporation requirements;
- Storage and treatment protocols.
Non-compliance can result in fines, lost subsidies, or environmental penalties - making raw manure increasingly risky to apply without further processing.
One promising and scientifically validated alternative is Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL) bioconversion. This process utilizes the larvae to rapidly consume and stabilize organic waste streams, including separated solid manure. Key outcomes include:
Frass derived from BSFL systems is often dry, easily stored, odorless, and meets compost-like safety standards, allowing for precision application and reduced environmental risk.
- Volume reduction: Up to 60-70% reduction in solids;
- Stabilized nutrient output: Frass with predictable NPK ratios, low pathogen load, and improved nutrient availability;
- Biomass generation: Insect protein suitable for animal feed;
- Improved soil performance: Frass promotes microbial activity and enhances long-term fertility.
Frass derived from BSFL systems is often dry, easily stored, odorless, and meets compost-like safety standards, allowing for precision application and reduced environmental risk.
Emerging Alternatives: Insect-Based Manure Bioconversion
Converting manure into insect feed and frass aligns with the principles of circular agriculture and nutrient recycling. It enables:
In its untreated form, manure poses serious environmental, regulatory, and agronomic risks. However, with scientific innovations like BSFL bioconversion, farms can convert manure from a liability into a valuable input for feed and soil fertility - safely, efficiently, and sustainably.
- Recovery of nutrients in a usable, transportable form;
- On-farm protein production, reducing external feed input dependency;
- Reduction of greenhouse gas emissions associated with raw slurry storage and landspreading;
- Compliance with climate-smart agriculture goals and EU Green Deal targets.
In its untreated form, manure poses serious environmental, regulatory, and agronomic risks. However, with scientific innovations like BSFL bioconversion, farms can convert manure from a liability into a valuable input for feed and soil fertility - safely, efficiently, and sustainably.
Manure management must evolve from disposal to transformation. The future lies in bio-based nutrient recovery - and insect-powered systems are leading the way.